Bad attitude
From
Vincent Coen@2:250/1 to
All on Monday, November 16, 2026 16:35:22
Analysis found the Air Arabia Maroc A320 recovered just 40ft above water - ANSV
Eighty years after it was first identified, the potentially lethal somatogravic
illusion trap is still snaring unwary pilots despite advances in air transport training.
The blend of circumstances preceding the extraordinary Air Arabia Maroc A320 incident near Catania - darkness, featureless sea, a lightly-laden aircraft and
a crew under pressure - could hardly have been more conducive.
Investigators are also still considering whether the Learjet 55 ambulance crash
in Philadelphia resulted from similar disorientation.
Although pilots are taught to trust their instruments rather than respond instinctively to sensation, there are limited opportunities to put that theory into practice through direct experience.
Somewhat ironically, pilots trained in a full-flight simulators routinely encounter the somatogravic illusion, played out in reverse: simulators generate
the sense of acceleration during take-off by pitching upwards, while keeping the visual horizon unaltered, tricking the brain into misinterpreting the effect on the vestibular system.
But the effect is only one-way. Standard hexapod simulators are unable to demonstrate how genuine acceleration can be mistaken for excessive pitch.
The Catania A320 inquiry found that the aircraft's captain could have perceived
the initial climb as 20 degrees nose-up, and possibly more, even as the jet - which never achieved more than 11 degrees pitch was transitioning to a nose-down attitude.
Earlier this year the US FAA issued a recommendation that operators of smaller aircraft - including business jets - be exposed to practical training involving
'stimuli likely to produce [spatial disorientation]', either using an aircraft or a suitable ground-based device.
'Such exposure allows the pilot to correlate sensations and perceptions experienced during [spatial disorientation] with the knowledge obtained from theoretical training,' it stated.
Large aircraft, however, do not respond in the same way as smaller types. And while a greater emphasis on upset-recovery training has been introduced into airline pilot training, it still leans heavily on the theoretical.
There are limitations regarding the fidelity of regular simulators and the parameters to which they are programmed. Going beyond accurate modelling of the
flight envelope could result in negative transfer of training to actual flight.
Until airline pilots can authentically experience the conflict between vestibular cue and instrument reality, and narrow the gap with theoretical knowledge, the defence will continue to rest almost entirely on discipline, monitoring and procedure.
You might have missed --
Airbus clarifies stabiliser jam procedure after pilot manually mis-trimmed A321
Air France jet descending towards Paris trimmed in accordance with direct rather than alternate law.
----
Fatal skydive crash pilot failed to pull Caravan out of intentional steep descent
Aircraft initially followed post-jump profile of previous flights before exceeding maximum speed limit.
----
Cockpit-voice recorder of crashed Learjet 60 retrieved from impact crater
Investigators complete excavation work at Florida site of fatal high-speed executive jet accident.
----
Pitch-up effect after bounced touchdown led A300 freighter to strike tail at London Heathrow
Crew executed go-around despite activating reverse thrust upon arrival from Leipzig.
From Flight Global Safety Briefing
--- Mageia Linux v10 X64/Mbse v1.1.7.2/GoldED+/LNX 1.1.5-b20260304
* Origin: Air Applewood, The Linux Gateway to the UK & Eire (2:250/1)